Ordination of Women

[I made this argument in a comment over at the Fearsome Pirate; I'm posting it here (at the suggestion of Evan Donovan) to give everybody a bigger target.]

OK, here is a substantive argument against the ordination of women (the individual points don't work individually, they have to be taken together):

1. The Saviour chose no women apostles and (so far as we know) commissioned no women to teach or exercise the power of the keys

2. St Paul forbade women to teach or have authority over men in the Church. Among other things, this suggests how St Paul interpreted the fact that Christ appointed no women apostles.

3. There were no women bishops or presbyters in the early centuries of the Church. This indicates that St Paul's take on the matter was not his personal opinion, but the consensus among the Apostles which was handed down to their successors.

4. In the third century, the principal point at issue between the Montanist heretics and the orthodox was the reliability of the Apostolic Tradition, compared to the "new revelations of the Holy Spirit" that the Montanists were claiming. One of the principal arguments against the Montanists was that their practice of ordaining women proved that they were not faithful to the Apostolic Tradition. This indicates that the ordination of men only to the presbyterate and the episcopate was part of the authentic teaching of the Apostles.

5. The canon law of the early Church specifically forbade the ordination of women to the presbyterate and episcopate. These canons were endorsed by the Council of Nicaea which gave us our Creed. You could say that Nicaea got the Apostolic Tradition wrong on this point, but they sure got it right in the Creed, so I don't think so.

You can interpret Scripture to allow women pastors, by attributing St Paul's strictures against it as either his personal opinion or as applicable only to his time and place. But there's a right way and a wrong way to interpret Scripture, and the consistent and specific understanding of Scripture on the part of orthodox Christianity through the centuries is a pretty reliable guide. Choosing one's interpretation to conform to current understandings of "equality" is not.

Comments

[Brian]

You don't mention once that the Scriptures are inspired and infallible. This is where your argument is weak, and where it can be successfully attacked by feminists who do not fear God. You were right that they would attack Paul's "personal opinion." These days they'd be more likely to say that his prohibition on women teaching in the church was "only applicable in those times."

If you do not argue that the Scriptures are inspired, you run the risk of relying solely upon "tradition" as Romanists do in defending the Papacy. You become a hypocrite, and you cannot expect to formulate logical Christian arguments defending anything that Scripture forbids (including sexual immorality, etc.)

[Christopher Jones]

The normative authority of Scripture in matters such as this is a given, Brian. What is at issue here is not whether or not the Scriptures are inspired and infallible, but whether or not the Scriptures may be legitimately interpreted to allow the ordination of women to the pastoral office. I believe that to interpret Scripture to allow it is not legitimate, and I have given my reasons why I so believe; it is precisely because I believe that the Scriptures, correctly interpreted, are the final word that I have laid out the reasons why my interpretation is correct.

To have a healthy respect for tradition as a guide to the correct interpretation of Scripture is not at all the same as "relying solely upon tradition as Romanists do." I have not done that. I have used tradition only as historical evidence as to how the Church has always understood Scripture. That is a different thing from relying on tradition as an authority distinct from Scripture.

[Heidt]

Good summation - but you leave out a key issue: if sacraments are sure and certain signs of grace, so too must their ministers be unambiguously valid. This is not the case with women priests, who therefore destroy the certainty of the sacramental principle itself.

This argument is simply ignored by its adversaries, who don't believe in sacramental objectivity. Thus we're left with the odd spectacle of women fighting very hard to be something they don't believe in anyway...

Cheers,

MLH+

[Biris]

ah ha I see where you r coming form but you forget one issue concerniong the apostolic misyogonistic devaluation of the ifalluble representatio of the 'male god!!'

[Pastor Thomas/Marie Dean]

God has no respect of person. The finished work of Calvary proves that He is Soveriegn. Where were the men (Apostles) when the heat was turn up on the Cross? In todays' times do you think a person struggling with various addictions is more concerned about a title or hearing the Good News regardless what gender delivers the message. Matthew Henry says, "those who mock God's Messengers forfiet the benefit of the message". Their were prophetess' in the old and new testament. In these last days the Body of Christ needs soldiers (male and female). I find it interesting that women can and are expected to do everything but stand on that man made piece of wood called the pulpipt! God Bless!!

[Cheap]

Thus we're left with the odd spectacle of women fighting very hard to be something they don't believe in anyway

[bGennavaro]

iphone 4 unlock
how to unlock iphone 4
unlock iphone 4

http://www.chicanochronicles.com/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=470565 http://bookmarkwheel.com/story.php?id=48448#discuss
i have a problem with my internal HDD. When this all happened, i was playing a game online. I got a Virus Worm and i shut down my computer and reformatted my HDD and put windows back on. I had a secondary HDD in for back-up purposes. so got windows in and put everything back, but i then noticed that my computers performance went down drastically with my main HDD, I could not copy anything i had onto the back-up drive and once i did it was so slow to copy the file. Once i had all the files on the back-up drive, i decided to start from the back-up drive with windows. Same applied. It was really slow with the reading-and-writing. i decided to take the secondary back-up drive out and boot from the main HDD. Everything seemed to be running smoothly i checked the main HDD Temperature with HD tune. The drives temp was 37 degrees Celsius, and the drive went to normal temperature of 43-44 degrees Celsius. I then decided to plug in the secondary HDD and leave it on for a day. the temperature went from 43-44 degrees to 47-48 degrees Celsius. So my guess is that the HDD drives are getting way to hot, and i am getting what seems like bad sectors in the drive, but it has never done this before. I have always had my back-up drive in ever since i got my main HDD. I can't place my finger on what is wrong with my drives. Once the main HDD is lower temperatures the drive seems to be performing better. but its normal temperature is 43-44 degrees Celsius and i still have some problems with reading and writing then. Can someone tell me what has happened please. I dont know if it was from the worm virus or if the temperatures are getting too hot (but has never done this before) can someone tell me what to do. I have changed the line leading into the motherboard as well, and that seems to have no effect. i even swapped the board lines between the CD drives and the HDD drives, no effect on that either. can someone tell me what is going on, i have ran out of options.
unlock iphone 4 unlock iphone 4

iphone 4 unlock iphone 4 unlock iphone 4 unlock unlock iphone 4

[rheuttzc]

mv8zw, acomplia, hf7iq, acomplia price us, acomplia for sale, ab3rc, acomplia online bestellen forum, http://mixmasteronlinefr.ning.com/profiles/blogs/buying-cheap-generic-acomplia-rimonabant cheap acomplia, me3xa, acomplia purchase, xf9wc

[efDejhfuC]

http://buysynthroidonline551.posterous.com buy synthroid online
http://buyreviaonline550.posterous.com buy revia online
http://buydiflucanonline892.posterous.com buy diflucan online
http://buylopressoronline.webnode.com buy lopressor online
http://buy-seroquelonline.webnode.com buy seroquel online

[ehhVjjhjD]

buy proscar online
buy cymbalta online
buy seroquel online
buy priligy online
buy glucophage online

[tawxxkei]

http://cipro10days405.posterous.com cipro 10 days
http://ciproglutenfree917.posterous.com cipro gluten free
http://ciprolevaquin444.posterous.com cipro levaquin
http://ciprokidneyfailure565.posterous.com cipro kidney failure
http://ciprowhatisitusedfor711.posterous.com cipro what is it used for

[jxrhtrat]

http://propeciathinninghair158.posterous.com propecia thinning hair
http://propeciafda417.posterous.com propecia fda
http://propeciausa445.posterous.com propecia usa
http://propeciayminoxidil487.posterous.com propecia y minoxidil
http://propeciareviews318.posterous.com propecia reviews

[yrwjvypl]

http://ciproxrtablets162.posterous.com cipro xr tablets
http://ciprolongtermsideeffects177.posterous.com cipro long term side effects
http://cipro10days405.posterous.com cipro 10 days
http://ciproglutenfree917.posterous.com cipro gluten free
http://ciprolevaquin444.posterous.com cipro levaquin

[abnolaber]

http://drinking-wine-on-abilify613.posterous.com drinking wine on abilify
http://abilify-side-effects621.posterous.com abilify side-effects
http://abilify-paranoid-schizophrenia190.posterous.com abilify paranoid schizophrenia

[Purchase xanax overnight]

vzadsqmfspnb, Xanax pharmacy, TVflfyp, [url=http://www.oldno9.org/facility.html]Xanax online pharmacy canada[/url], xqVdWlI, http://www.oldno9.org/facility.html Cheap xanax bars, uZXlkLw.

[Tramadol]

dknmcqmfspnb, Tadalafil tablets, DGNHNUp, [url=http://www.tadalafilpricecompare.com/]Cheapest generic tadalafil[/url], axgWCum, http://www.tadalafilpricecompare.com/ Tadalafil e20, kZkFnKb, Powered by smugmug new comment link online pharmacy tramadol, qRNAjnb, [url=http://www.mwinstonltd.com/]Buy tramadol best price online[/url], dJPetVs, http://www.mwinstonltd.com/ Is tramadol sulfa based, SrcfxME, Bowtrol colon cleansing, QbTfdpa, [url=http://getbowtrol.com/]Bowtrol gnc[/url], QCFMUkQ, http://getbowtrol.com/ Bowtrol colon cleanser, rITBncs, Cheap cialis, QPGQgOR, [url=http://www.vanessa-hudgensonline.com/]How long does it take cialis to work[/url], fSjbtur, http://www.vanessa-hudgensonline.com/ Cheap cialis in uk, llwQcUF, Accutane lawsuits pa, jyBkKmh, [url=http://www.onlinemedsreview.com/ViewMedInfo_217.html]Accutane[/url], LryHbAM, http://www.onlinemedsreview.com/ViewMedInfo_217.html Arkansas accutane lawyers, RecLiES, Smoketip consumer reviews, uQhDNEh, [url=http://myecigsreviews.com/category/smoketip]Smoketip reviews[/url], CFsxVbb, http://myecigsreviews.com/category/smoketip Smoketip electronic cigarette review, wfwdqpt.

[Ambien]

axaleqmfspnb, Flexeril for dogs, jPdqUkW, [url=http://www.flexerilpharm.com/]Flexeril and xanax[/url], pyQvVCa, http://www.flexerilpharm.com/ Flexeril longterm effects, KSnWgCD, Generic viagra, RiKwmsy, [url=http://www.esportspartners.com/viagra.html]Viagra side effects[/url], QhLaOaF, http://www.esportspartners.com/viagra.html Generic Viagra, HanXEgN, HCG, bqfypEM, [url=http://dailyleft.com/]Hcg diet pellets[/url], TeANjwF, http://dailyleft.com/ 800 calorie hcg diet, lbvwrCh, Buy cheapest valium, RinpNbs, [url=http://www.goldenpawspetstylingacademyin.com/]Buy valium oniline[/url], MTDUSbx, http://www.goldenpawspetstylingacademyin.com/ Where can i buy valium on the internet, ruKRMmL, Thesafecig, EllaFnq, [url=http://ecigbrandsreview.com/reviews/the-safe-cig-thesafecig-review-the-smallest-and-smartest-e-cigarette]Thesafecig[/url], RpdFxdE, http://ecigbrandsreview.com/reviews/the-safe-cig-thesafecig-review-the-smallest-and-smartest-e-cigarette Thesafecig, LpDwfqc, Ambien without a prescription, bXbVcga, [url=http://www.henrysdiner.net/contact.html]Ambien[/url], GVEYBnc, http://www.henrysdiner.net/contact.html Ambien cr side effects, yNmDgtI.

[Online pharmacy store]

didykqmfspnb, No prescription online pharmacy, yzESlUa, [url=http://www.mwinstonltd.com/services.html]Codeine online pharmacy[/url], VVIWUph, http://www.mwinstonltd.com/services.html Adipex online pharmacy, XaGnhbg.

[Online pharmacy store]

didykqmfspnb, No prescription online pharmacy, yzESlUa, [url=http://www.mwinstonltd.com/services.html]Codeine online pharmacy[/url], VVIWUph, http://www.mwinstonltd.com/services.html Adipex online pharmacy, XaGnhbg.

[Levitra]

nrgkgqmfspnb, Levitra ordonnance, oYCgrBJ, [url=http://www.treatimpotencenow.com/category/levitra]Levitra[/url], VFSkFIe, http://www.treatimpotencenow.com/category/levitra Bayer levitra, bXHkPIk.

[Levitra]

nrgkgqmfspnb, Levitra ordonnance, oYCgrBJ, [url=http://www.treatimpotencenow.com/category/levitra]Levitra[/url], VFSkFIe, http://www.treatimpotencenow.com/category/levitra Bayer levitra, bXHkPIk.

[Does finasteride cause constipation]

zzjbqqmfspnb, Free divx codec, PCQZWQm, [url=http://divxcodec-advice.org/]Divx pro codec 6.9.2[/url], fyRTnuX, http://divxcodec-advice.org/ Divx Codec, dnHpLJr, Dark shell megaupload, pkjleEV, [url=http://megaupload-access.com/]Mega Upload[/url], ReEsbsc, http://megaupload-access.com/ Megaupload, KDCMjby, nutrascience reviews, iSythkl, [url=http://healthyweightlosstrends.com/reviews/nutra-science-review]nutrascience[/url], uMrxwrg, http://healthyweightlosstrends.com/reviews/nutra-science-review nutrascience, VcYUbIF, Finasteride medicine, hqFoqsZ, [url=http://www.flannerys.net/about.html]Finasteride[/url], ikpcbUO, http://www.flannerys.net/about.html Finasteride no rx 5 m, QNyZSju, Webcam, ahCmNBZ, [url=http://123webcam.org/]Chicas con webcam[/url], rGPRake, http://123webcam.org/ Sex webcam, ydOtNVF, Provigil and weight, vOdvtFM, [url=http://www.promotewakefulness.com/]Order provigil[/url], CxAqMvJ, http://www.promotewakefulness.com/ Provigil, aiSejiK.

[Carisoprodol cyclobenzaprine]

yuuutqmfspnb, Buy carisoprodol without prescription, uDJrgDT, [url=http://crossoverlouisville.com/blog/]Carisoprodol 700 mg[/url], ntGrJuP, http://crossoverlouisville.com/blog/ Muscle relaxer, UKunbZB.

[how to improve your eyesight]

xtassqmfspnb, Ambien dosage, jKpGErF, [url=http://mdmhome.com/]Ambien sample[/url], pihvbyL, http://mdmhome.com/ Ambien habit, myyUxxE, Acai berry advertisement, rHvLxEe, [url=http://acai-blog.net/]Acai berry easy cleanse[/url], UxDShjx, http://acai-blog.net/ Acai, COXlsSc, Plastered how to get rid of cellulite on legs leave a reply name email comment, kxuinjT, [url=http://cellulite-guide.org/]Garter how to get rid of cellulite leave a reply name email comment[/url], EOddIFH, http://cellulite-guide.org/ Cellulite, LVQYRDh, how to improve your eyesight, FhfeLtf, [url=http://govisionwithoutglasses.com/]eye exercises[/url], Awunkbd, http://govisionwithoutglasses.com/ how to improve eyesight, vLbElaW, Semenax.c, aIGNhuI, [url=http://discountsemenaxpills.com/]Semenax[/url], pqrYrlu, http://discountsemenaxpills.com/ Semenax, tmauXYo, Kids chat, RQbFRSo, [url=http://kidsabc.info/]Kids birthday cakes designs[/url], RccJQZo, http://kidsabc.info/ Games for kids, lnsOutq.

[Online Reputation Management]

uuynvqmfspnb, Buy Ambien, qqudGgW, [url=http://www.mikecaracciolo.com/about.asp]Ambien[/url], kIjVMei, http://www.mikecaracciolo.com/about.asp What color is ambien cr, HzatDEm, Zolpidem tartrate for sale, YgxHbiI, [url=http://www.lightbodies.com/]Zolpidem[/url], tEbfTcm, http://www.lightbodies.com/ Zolpidem how much can you take, ZZnXKGp, Cheap cialis tablets, StWfGOE, [url=http://www.carriagebandb.com/reservations.html]Buy Cialis[/url], YwbJJMR, http://www.carriagebandb.com/reservations.html Cialis, PgdrwBn, Order ambien cheap, OzbHEIA, [url=http://alltolled.com/mitchsmyths.htm]Ambien online no prescription[/url], goLbBTk, http://alltolled.com/mitchsmyths.htm Buy ambien online, VUlfNeR, Reputation defender management, eNKXmlK, [url=http://reputationmanagementdeluxe.com/]Reputation Management[/url], fkbWIhU, http://reputationmanagementdeluxe.com/ Hotel reputation management, gpPzXuS, Propecia, udlJoHi, [url=http://www.adamandcheri.com/rsvp.html]Propecia[/url], QkIuCxQ, http://www.adamandcheri.com/rsvp.html Generic Propecia, SUmnFYy.